Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner Review Best Long-Wearing Smudge-Proof Makeup

Description

Highlights of the Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner

Trying out the Rimmel London Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner, Long-Wearing, Ultra-Smooth, Smudge-Proof, 001, Black, 0.04oz was an interesting experience. The ultra-smooth and creamy formula really stood out to me as it glided effortlessly across my eyelids without tugging or skipping. This gel eyeliner delivers high intensity color that instantly grabs attention with its bold black pigment. Its waterproof, sweat-proof, and heat-proof properties kept my makeup intact even during a particularly rainy day and a sweaty gym session. I was impressed by how it resisted smudging, maintaining a crisp line throughout. For those with sensitive eyes like me, the fact that it is dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested offered some peace of mind, and I didn’t experience any irritation.

• Intense black color with impressive pigmentation
• Smooth application without dragging
• Long-lasting wear resistant to water, sweat, and heat

Drawbacks Worth Considering

Despite its many strong points, this gel pencil isn’t without flaws. The thin tip means it requires a bit of patience and precision, which might frustrate beginners aiming for a thicker, more dramatic line quickly. Also, the product wears down fairly quickly, so it demands frequent sharpening to maintain that perfect point, which can feel wasteful over time. I noticed that after several hours, especially in humid conditions, the eyeliner could slightly fade around the edges, though it never fully smudged or disappeared. For some users, the intensity of the black might be too bold for everyday subtle looks, requiring careful blending or lighter pressure during application.

• Requires frequent sharpening due to thin tip
• Slight fading after prolonged wear in humidity
• Bold pigment may not suit all makeup styles

Versatility and Ease of Use

This eyeliner is surprisingly versatile despite being marketed mainly for bold, intense looks. I experimented with a variety of styles—from sharp cat eyes to soft smudged edges—and found it adaptable enough to handle both. The creamy texture allows for easy blending right after application, but it sets quickly, so timing matters. This balance between blendability and quick setting is great for those who like to experiment but don’t want their makeup to run all day. The product’s compact size and pencil form make it convenient for touch-ups on the go, fitting easily in my makeup bag without taking much space.

Safety and Suitability for Sensitive Eyes

As someone prone to irritated eyes from makeup, I appreciated how this product is safe for sensitive eyes and has been tested by dermatologists and ophthalmologists. It caused no redness or discomfort during use, even when applied close to the waterline. This is a major plus compared to some competitors that can sting or cause watering. Family members with sensitive skin also gave it a try and reported no allergic reactions, which speaks to its gentle formula. This makes it a reliable choice for a wide range of users, especially those who struggle to find eye makeup that doesn’t aggravate their eyes.

Competing Brands and How This Product Stacks Up

Comparing this gel pencil to other popular waterproof eyeliners like Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama or L’Oréal Infallible Gel Crayon, the Rimmel offering holds its ground well. Its color payoff rivals many mid-range products, but the smoothness of application is superior in many ways, minimizing the tugging I’ve experienced with competitors. However, the Maybelline pencil tends to last slightly longer without fading, and L’Oréal’s version offers a wider shade range. Still, the Rimmel Scandaleyes stands out for its combination of affordability, intense pigmentation, and safety for sensitive eyes—features that aren’t always found together.

Price Worthiness and Value Assessment

Evaluating the price point alongside what this gel pencil offers, it represents a smart spending choice for anyone looking for a reliable, everyday waterproof eyeliner. It balances quality and cost-effectiveness, providing a product that doesn’t compromise on performance while being budget-friendly. Considering the ease of use, lasting power, and safety credentials, the investment feels justified. While it’s not the cheapest on the market, the combination of long-wear and gentle formula gives it an edge over many lower-cost alternatives that may irritate or fade quickly.

User Experience and Practical Application

My coworkers, who are casual makeup users, also gave this eyeliner a try. They remarked on the ease of drawing sharp lines and the confidence in its smudge-proof claim. One friend mentioned how it survived a full day at a conference without any touch-ups, even during a humid commute. My younger sister, who prefers a more natural look, found it a bit too intense but liked the option to smudge it softly before it dried. This feedback suggests the product suits a range of preferences but leans more toward those who appreciate bold eye makeup or need durability for active lifestyles.

Good Aspects That Make It Worth Considering

• Intense pigmentation ensures striking eye looks instantly
• The smooth, creamy texture glides on effortlessly
• Formula is waterproof, sweat-proof, and heat-proof for extended wear
• Tested for safety, making it ideal for sensitive eyes
• Compact and travel-friendly design

Areas for Improvement

• The thin tip requires frequent sharpening, which can be inconvenient
• Slight fading in extremely humid conditions is possible
• Intensity may be too much for users who want subtle makeup

Overall, this eyeliner delivers solid performance with a few minor quirks that can be overlooked by those prioritizing long-lasting, bold eye makeup. Its blend of color intensity, wear resistance, and gentle formula make it a dependable choice among gel pencil eyeliners.

Additional information